Rare & Hard to Find

Super NeeDoh Ripples Giant 4.5" Textured Sensory Squishy Choose Your Color Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Squishmas Christmas Advent Calendar |24 Days of Squishy Surprises Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Knittens 2026 Squishmas Sweater-Soft Holiday Kitten Choose Your Color Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Teenie Jack-Glow Lanterns Halloween Glow-in-the-Dark Pumpkin 3-Pack Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Shaggy Fuzzy Groovy Glob Sensory Squishy Choose Your Color Authentic Schylling

NeeDoh Monster Mush RARE Target Exclusive Squish-O-Ween Halloween Countdown 14 Surprises

NeeDoh Baby Boos 3-Pack Glow in the Dark Mini Ghosts Choose Glasses Variation Schylling

NeeDoh Funky Frights Squish-O-Ween Countdown 13 Halloween Squishies 2026 Schylling

NeeDoh Galactic Glow Dream Drop Glow in the Dark Sparkly Squishy Choose Your Color Schylling

NeeDoh Sugar Skull Cats Halloween Sugar Skull Squishies Choose Your Color Authentic Schylling

NeeDoh Groovy Fruit 3-Pack Banana, Strawberry & Orange Squishies Authentic Schylling

NeeDoh Fuzz Ball Wild Cats Rare Faces & Fur Patterns Choose Your Cat Authentic Schylling

NeeDoh Snow Ball Crunch Hard-to-Find Crunchy Snowball Sensory Squishy Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Polar Glow Penguins 2026 Glow in the Dark Choose Your Penguin Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Peace O' Cake Pink Top Rainbow Cake Squishy Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Jelly Dohnut | Pink Frosting & Purple Drizzle | Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Glowy Ghosts White Aldi Exclusive & Halloween Ghosts Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Groovy the Glowman Glow in the Dark Squishmas Snowman Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Squishmas Squishkins 4-Pack Santa Edition Authentic Schylling

RARE NeeDoh Barnyard Squishers Discontinued Tractor Supply Exclusive Schylling

NeeDoh Teenie Fuzz Ball Farmyard Set Tractor Supply Exclusive Authentic Schylling